Rule utilitarianism

Part of a series on Utilitarianism Predecessors Epicurus David Hume William Godwin Francis Hutcheson People Jeremy Bentham John Stuart Mill Henry Sidgwick Richard Mervyn Hare Peter Singer Types of utilitarianism Preference Rule Act Two-level Total Average Relative Negative Hedonism Enlightened self-interest Key concepts Pain Suffering Pleasure Utility Happiness Eudaimonia Consequentialism Felicific calculus Problems Mere addition paradox Paradox of hedonism Utility monster Related topics Rational choice theory Game theory Social choice Neoclassical economics Politics portal v d e

http://www.qwantz.com/archive/postcard/000599.html

Consequentialism 5: Act/Rule Utilitarianism (John C. Harsanyi)

Rule Consequentialism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)
The theory of morality we can call full rule-consequentialism selects rules solely in terms of the goodness ... Harsanyi, J., 1977, "Rule Utilitarianism and Decision Theory" ...

Rule utilitarianism is a form of utilitarianism that says actions are moral when they conform to the rules that lead to the greatest good or that "the rightness or wrongness of a particular action is a function of the correctness of the rule of which it is an instance."1 For rule utilitarians the correctness of a rule is determined by the amount of good it brings about when followed. In contrast act utilitarians judge actions in terms of the goodness of their consequences without reference to rules of action. Another variation of rule utilitarianism stresses the greater utility of following a given rule in general arguing that the practice of following some rule in all instances (always stopping at red lights for example) will have better consequences overall than allowing exceptions to be made in individual instances even if better consequences can be demonstrated in those instances. Rule utilitarianism can also be seen as practice rule which states thateven though in some or most cases the rule wouldn't cause the greatest goodnever following it would not cause the greatest good for the greatest number of people. For example the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution states "No person shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself." Even though that rule protects many criminals from conviction in its absence people could be tortured or threatened into confessing crimes they didn't commit. So if there were no fifth amendment it would not cause the greatest good for the greatest number of people. Contents 1 Mill's formulation 2 Specific criticism 3 See also 4 References 5 Further reading Mill's formulation

Bishop Berkeley 1685 1753 In framing the general laws of nature it is granted we must be entirely guided by the public good of mankind but not in the ordinary moral actions of our lives Such a rule if
http://www.utilitarianism.com/george-berkeley.html

Consequentialism 1: Utilitarianism Basics

Utilitarianism - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Both rule utilitarianism and act utilitarianism are teleological ... Rule utilitarianism has been criticized for advocating general rules that, in some ...

In his 1861 book Utilitarianism John Stuart Mill defends the concept of rights in terms of utility: "To have a right then is I conceive to have something which society ought to defend me in the possession of. If the objector goes on to ask why it ought I can give him no other reason than general utility."2 Whether Mill was a rule utilitarian is a matter of controversy;3 he also argues that it is sometimes right to violate general ethical rules:

The real trend in global history shows undoubtedly that there is a strong relationship between the development of technology and the fall of pain in the world Look at the drawing 1 It means that we have to focus on science and technologies that alleviate the pain We must also underline the role of education As a result we may write our second golden rule
http://www.freeworldacademy.com/spiritualodyssey/ethics.htm

A2 RS: Application of Utilitarianism (Act, Rule + Preference) to Business Ethics in 4mins

RULE-UTILITARIANISM
The purpose of the present work is to examine whether rule-utilitarianism could succeed in providing a ... examples that act-utilitarianism fails to resolve satisfactorily. ...

justice is a name for certain moral requirements which regarded collectively stand higher in the scale of social utility and are therefore of more paramount obligation than any others; though particular cases may occur in which some other social duty is so important as to overrule any one of the general maxims of justice. Thus to save a life it may not only be allowable but a duty to steal or take by force the necessary food or medicine or to kidnap and compel to officiate the only qualified medical practitioner.2

ought to act according to those rules of action which if generally adopted will produce the greatest possible balance of good over evil or the least possible balance of evil over good Rule Utilitarianism Moral Criterion Immediate Moral Criterion justified moral rules Ultimate Moral Criterion Classical Hedonic RU happiness suffering pleasure pain
http://catpages.nwmissouri.edu/m/rfield/nwcourses/274ppt/PP06.htm

AS Utilitarianism - Act, Rule, Preference and difficulties

utilitarianism: West's Encyclopedia of American Law (Full ...
utilitarianism n. The belief that the value of a thing or an action is determined by its ... Both rule utilitarianism and act utilitarianism are teleological (from the Greek ...

Other things being equal people are happier if their society follows rules so people know what types of behaviour they can expect from others in given situations. Therefore utilitarians can justify a system that goes "Keep to the rules unless there is a strong reason for breaking them." Specific criticism

work has stood the test of time I identify with a significant amount of utilitarian thought with emphasis on rule utilitarianism to my views of policy A few of his relevant quotes today War is an ugly thing but not the ugliest of things The decayed and degraded state of moral and patriotic feeling which thinks that nothing is worth war is much worse The person who has
http://nogovernmentcheese.blogspot.com/2005_05_01_archive.html

Fred & Phil Show 1

UTILITARIANISM
Rule Utilitarianism is an option for those who believe that there are absolute ... Rule Utilitarianism: An action or policy is morally right if and only if it is ...

A specific criticism of rule utilitarianism states that it collapses into act utilitarianism. David Lyons4 argued that collapse occurs because for any given rule in the case where breaking the rule produces more utility the rule can be sophisticated by the addition of a sub-rule that handles cases like the exception. This process holds for all cases of exceptions and so the rules will have as many sub-rules as there are exceptional cases which in the end makes an agent seek out whatever outcome produces the maximum utility.5 See also Act utilitarianism Two-level utilitarianism Preference utilitarianism John Stuart Mill Ludwig von Mises Richard Brandt Henry Hazlitt Brad Hooker Peter Singer Rule egoism References Garner Richard T.; Bernard Rosen (1967). Moral Philosophy: A Systematic Introduction to Normative Ethics and Meta-ethics. New York: Macmillan. p. 70. ISBN 0023405805. a b Mill John Stuart (1861). Utilitarianism. "Rule Consequentialism". Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 2003-12-31. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/consequentialism-rule/. Retrieved 2007-03-11. Forms and Limits of Utilitarianism 1965. Allen Habib (2008) "Promises" in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Further reading Brad Hooker's entry on rule consequentialism in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: 1 Brad Hooker Ideal Code Real World Oxford University Press 2000 new edition 2002 Foundations of Morality at the Mises Institute Hazlitt Henry (1964). The Foundations of Morality. Irvington-on-HudsonNY: Foundation for Economic Education. Smart J. J. C. "Extreme and Restricted Utilitarianism". The Victorian Branch of the Australasian Association of Psychology and Philosophy (October 1955).

http://www.ethicallyspeaking.org/

2/8 Christopher Hitchens vs Robert Wright on Religion

Utilitarianism - Definition | WordIQ.com
Utilitarianism is both a theory of the good and a theory of the right. ... A common alternative form is rule utilitarianism, which states that the best act ...

This is a difficult one to describe I was a little crazy when I thought about the idea for this piece It was originally a concept for my GCSE Art exam which didn t work The theme was imagination and I had just been reading the book Hard Times in English class This made the connection about wait for it Utilitarianism which means the suppression of imagination by facts In this picture the imagination is trying to escape the rule of the cage or Utilitarianism by getting the keys
http://www.flickr.com/photos/27860950@N07/3205014000/

Sex & Ethics - Utilitarianism

Rule-Utilitarianism:Bridging the Gap between Consequentialist ...
Rule-Utilitarianism:Bridging the Gap between Consequentialist and ... Third, I will show how rule-utilitarianism better accommodates for our moral intuitions ...

to the rule On the other hand if we say that in general x behaviour leads to y outcome then we appear to have some basis for evaluating whether what we are doing is right or not Something to discuss On the 1st December 1955 Rosa Parks refused to give up her seat on a bus in Montgomery Alabama for white passengers Her actions led to the Montgomery Bus Boycott
http://www.thatreligiousstudieswebsite.com/Ethics/Moral_Theory/Utilitarianism/utilitarianism2_intro.php

7/8 Christopher Hitchens vs Robert Wright on Religion

Ethics Text page
Utilitarianism was originally proposed in 18th century England by ... Rule utilitarianism instead states that the best act is to follow the general rule which ...

this here is a small muji pot filled with noodler s black ink reflecting in a curious manner the ska tastic cover of a 50 cent composition book i ve been going on a small muji binge lately i suppose that whenever my life is untidy and irregular i crave the neatness and japanese rationality that muji promises i go to the shop just to feel things they make me feel a little bit saner tonight i bought two of these little pots one to put ink in for travelling as above and one i donno it was pretty anyway i am trying not to fall into the muji trap that makes one believe that just because it has the kanji and the maroon and tan tag it s inherently better the notebook above por ej is your bog standard american <a href http en wikipedia org wiki Composition notebook >composition notebook< a> which have become my weapon of choice i mean the closest analogue i can find on these fair shores are the thin b5 muji cahiers but they just aren t right they just don t have that chunky rugged tactility those rounded corners that single signature stitched binding wait no actually they do have that bit and as cheap as they are they don t have a pin on the fact that i went to walmart in july and bought a stack for fiddy cent each please disregard the fact that i just ordered four quad rule comp books from staples in the US for 3 bucks a throw that is irrelevant at this point the point is that it is easy to consider minimal japanese design to be the ultimate to be the balm to all that ails but the truth is that sometimes plain old ass american utilitarianism with its walmartness and ugly fonts just works better the utter approachability of comp books is what invites me to use them to write in instead of intimidating me with their pristinity anyway so i was thinking about muji lately as much as i aspire to the clean trappings of a modern japanese lifestyle the truth is that i actually go in more for american minimalism comp books and parker 51s levis and vans if it
http://www.flickr.com/photos/candace/3062431186/

8/8 Christopher Hitchens vs Robert Wright on Religion

Consequentialism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)
Rule utilitarianism faces several potential counterexamples (such as whether ... Anyway, even if rule utilitarianism accords with some common substantive moral ...

with the shorthand which will save much time later This candidate is in total command of the material and knows where he she is going Clear Distinction Plus First impression Brilliant The Bad In order to answer this question it is necessary to first define Act Utilitarianism and Rule Utilitarianism and then to investigate whether Mill was an act or a rule utilitarian
http://users.ox.ac.uk/~ball0888/oxfordopen/paragraphs.htm

Consequentialist Ethics: Utilitarianism